Midtown’s Must-Try Empanadas: A Guide to the Best Food in Times Square

Times Square has a pulse all its own. The flashing lights, packed sidewalks, and street performers create a kind of energy that is hard to describe until you are experiencing it yourself. As locals and regular city wanderers, we have seen how overwhelming it can be to choose where to eat in this iconic neighborhood. Tourists often settle for the most obvious or convenient food options, like basic pizza or expensive chain restaurants, without realizing there are much better, more unique, and authentic food experiences nearby.

One of the best discoveries ever made is how perfect empanadas are for this fast-paced city, no, we are not kidding. They are warm, flavorful, easy to carry, and full of surprises. And when it comes to finding the best ones around, there’s one place that locals and travelers keep coming back to: Empanada Mama. Tucked just close enough to the chaos of Times Square but with its own vibe, it is where we head for real flavor. We are sharing exactly where to go and what to try for the best food in Times Square.

Hungry in Times Square? Here’s what most tourists get wrong.

What Makes Empanadas the Perfect Midtown Bite?

We have always believed that the best food tells a story, and empanadas are no exception. Originating from Latin America and Spain, empanadas are hand-held pastries filled with flavorful ingredients like meats, cheeses, vegetables, or even something sweet. They are shaped like half-moons and baked or fried to golden perfection.

In the middle of Manhattan’s madness, that kind of food just makes sense. No need for forks, fancy setups, or long wait times. Just delicious, freshly made bites that travel with you. It is food designed for motion, yet packed with heritage and flavor. That is exactly why we think empanadas are the perfect Midtown bite.

Why Empanada Mama Stands Out in Times Square

Empanada Mama brings a little slice of Latin America right into the heart of Times Square. Our roots are deeply connected to Colombian flavors and traditions and heart with Times Square empanadas, which means every empanada is filled with bold and vibrant tastes. 

The energy of Times Square matches our vibe perfectly. Since the city never sleeps, we keep our doors open till late, making us a favorite for tourists rushing between shows as well as locals looking for a quick and tasty bite.

For those exploring other parts of New York, Empanada Mama also has welcoming spots in Hell’s Kitchen, the East Village, and the Upper East Side. No matter which location you visit, you can expect fresh, flavorful empanadas that keep everyone coming back for more.

What to Order: 5 Must-Try Empanadas at Empanada Mama

If you’re looking for the best empanadas in Midtown, Empanada Mama has some seriously delicious options that will have you coming back for more. We’ve got something for every kind of craving, from spicy and savory to uniquely flavorful. Let’s jump into five must-try empanadas that perfectly capture what makes our menu a Midtown favorite.

#1 Viagra Empanada:

The Viagra Empanada is packed with fresh shrimp and crab meat in a savory seafood stew that’s bursting with flavor. If you love seafood, this one is a standout choice that’s totally worth trying.

#2 Spicy Chicken Empanada:

You can’t miss the Spicy Chicken Empanada, filled with tender chicken breast slow-cooked in a spicy picante sauce. Just the right kick of heat wrapped in rich, doughy comfort. It’s flavor and feel-good vibes in one bite.

#3 Bombay Empanada:

If you want to try something a bit different, try  Bombay Empanada. It brings bold Indian spices into the mix. Filled with curried chicken, chickpeas, cilantro, and scallions, a unique flavor adventure right here in Times Square.

#4 Cheeseburger Wheat Empanada:

This one feels like your two favorite comfort foods rolled into one. We cook ground beef in traditional Latin spices, mix in sharp cheddar cheese, and wrap it all up in our wheat flour dough. It’s familiar, satisfying, and a favorite for anyone craving that classic burger flavor with a Latin twist.

#5 Romeo & Juliet Dessert:

For a sweet finish, the Romeo & Juliet combines guava and mozzarella cheese, offering a delightful balance of sweet and savory.

All these empanadas are perfect for grabbing on-the-go or savoring as a quick Midtown meal. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, Empanada Mama offers the best empanadas in Midtown that will keep your taste buds happy and your belly full.

Ambience, Price & What to Expect

Empanada Mama has a casual, friendly vibe that fits perfectly with the energy of Midtown. It’s open 24 hours so whether you’re craving a late-night snack or a quick lunch, it’s always ready to serve.

Most empanadas cost under $10, making it a budget-friendly stop for some of the best food Times Square has to offer. The service is quick, whether you want to sit down or take your food to go.

This spot is loved by locals, tourists, and foodies who want tasty, fast bites without fuss. If you want the best food Times Square has, Empanada Mama is a must-visit for a delicious and easy empanada experience.

Know Before You Go: Quick Tips for Foodies in Times Square

Want to skip the crowd? Visit Empanada Mama in the late morning or mid-afternoon. Things get busy after Broadway shows but we are open 24 hours, so there is always time for a snack.

We accept cards and digital payments. There is cozy seating and takeout is quick and easy. You can also order online for delivery right to your door which is perfect if you want the best food in Times Square without leaving your place.

Locals know the best bites in Midtown are not flashy. They are warm, handmade, and full of flavor. That is exactly what you will find here.

Bonus: Other Worthwhile Empanada Spots Nearby

If you're on an empanada crawl through Midtown, there are a few other spots worth checking out. Nuchas offers creative handheld options with bold fillings and is just a short walk from Times Square. Empellón serves Latin-inspired dishes with a contemporary twist, for those exploring options nearby. Sophie’s Cuban Cuisine is another solid pick for hearty empanadas and more traditional Cuban fare.

Each spot has its own flair, so feel free to explore. A good foodie always leaves room for just one more bite.

Why Empanada Mama Is a Can’t-Miss Stop in Times Square 

In the bustling heart of Times Square, Empanada Mama stands out for one simple reason: authenticity meets innovation. Unlike the typical fast food options, our empanadas are crafted fresh daily with high-quality ingredients and bold flavors that reflect real Latin roots.

What sets Empanada Mama apart? It’s our unique variety of fillings, from perfectly spiced meats and fresh seafood to cheesy blends and surprisingly sweet options. Plus, we cater to all dietary needs, including gluten-free and vegetarian choices, making sure everyone finds something to love.

Our friendly, fast service means you get a satisfying meal without missing a beat in your busy Times Square adventure. Plus, being open 24/7 means you can indulge anytime.

Explore our menu to find an option that suits you. There’s something here for every kind of foodie.

Next time you’re near Times Square, don’t miss this gem.